Thursday, April 17, 2025

Well: The downside of getting what you want

Plus: post-workout massages, 'sleep divorces' and rejection sensitivity
All NewslettersRead online
New York Times logo
Well
For subscribersApril 17, 2025
A photo of a blue bowed gift box with the top off and leaning on the box. The box is also a tissue box.
Illustration by Matt Chase; Photographs by Shutterstock

The downside of getting what you want

A friend of mine is retiring after dreaming about it for years. Yet when he packed up his office, he burst into tears. "I have no idea why," he told me. "I've wanted out forever."

We expect some life transitions to be difficult, like a serious illness or the end of a relationship. But others — a new house, a marriage, a promotion — are more positive. You should be happy, so why do you feel sad?

Because with change comes loss, said Alan Wolfelt, a grief counselor and director of the Center for Loss & Life Transition in Fort Collins, Colo. "Anytime you're gaining something new in life, you're giving something else up," he said. And sometimes the result is grief, he added.

So how do you handle the unexpected emotions? I asked experts for guidance.

Recognize your grief.

We often associate grief with death, but it can crop up during any loss. And telling yourself that you should be happy only makes you feel worse, said Anthony Chambers, a psychologist and chief academic officer of the Family Institute at Northwestern University.

He suggests clarifying your muddled emotions by asking yourself these questions: What am I feeling and why am I feeling this way? What am I losing with this gain? What did I appreciate about my previous stage of life?

If you feel grief, that doesn't mean you made the wrong choice, Dr. Chambers said. It's just part of your adjustment to this new chapter, he added.

Let yourself mourn.

While grief is an internal response, Dr. Wolfelt said, mourning is "being able to share those thoughts and feelings outwardly."

Everyone processes grief differently, he said. You can write in a journal, talk to others who are in similar situations or express yourself through art or music, he said.

Whatever you do, try to be honest when people ask you about these transitions, said Doris Vaughans, a licensed professional counselor at the Portland Institute for Loss and Transition.

"People will say things like, 'Oh, you're retiring? How wonderful, you must be so happy,'" Dr. Vaughans said. "You can say something like, 'Yes, I'm happy and I'm sad. Now I don't know how to be this new person, because I haven't done it yet.'"

And if you're having a lot of trouble moving forward, consider talking to a therapist or joining a support group, Dr. Vaughans added. Overwhelmed new parents, for example, can contact Postpartum Support International, a nonprofit organization that offers free support groups online for parents of all kinds (not just those with postpartum depression).

Plan for a "well-rounded ending."

When we start a new chapter in life, "in our minds, we are already on to the future," said Gabriele Oettingen, a professor of psychology at New York University.

She gave an example of the graduating students at N.Y.U. who, with several months until graduation, tended to focus on leaving school and preparing for job interviews, she said. "But afterwards, they say they regret that they didn't spend enough time with their friends," she said.

Dr. Oettingen's research suggests we're more likely to have positive feelings about transitioning from one stage of life to the next if we have a "well-rounded ending," one that's marked by a sense of closure.

If subjects felt they had tied up the loose ends, Dr. Oettingen said, they felt happier, experienced less regret and were more able to concentrate on the next phase of their lives.

So if you're approaching a transition, look for ways to commemorate it, Dr. Oettingen recommended. If, like my friend, you're anticipating retirement, try savoring all the things you like about the job such as the coffee shop next to your workplace or lunch with your favorite colleagues, Dr. Oettingen said. And consider a ritual like a goodbye party, she added.

Look for parts of your old identity that you can recreate.

Dr. Vaughans encourages her clients to ask themselves, "What specifically am I missing, and is there a way I could get some of that back in a different form?"

I got creative when I moved from Brooklyn to the New Jersey suburbs. I had been ready to relocate but found myself missing my old neighborhood.

Then one night I heard an ice cream truck. I was overjoyed because it used the same music I heard through 20 Brooklyn summers. I made friends with the ice cream man, bought plenty of cones with rainbow sprinkles, and now the guy parks in front of my house and plays that music until I come out.

Like this email?
Forward it to your friends, and let them know they can sign up here.

A small trash can with it's lid open containing empty alcohol bottles and cigarette boxes.
Joyce Lee for The New York Times

Do you have a family history of cancer? Here's how to reduce your odds of getting the disease.

While it's true that your risk of cancer is higher if you have a family history, getting sick is not inevitable. One study estimated that about 40 percent of cases were caused by lifestyle factors you can change.

Read the article: Cancer Runs in My Family. How Can I Cut My Risk?

A grid of nine photographs of asparagus on a purple background.
Suzanne Saroff for The New York Times

Asparagus has surprising health benefits.

Spring is the peak season for asparagus. Learn about the many nutrients it contains, as well as fresh ways to prepare asparagus from New York Times Cooking.

Read the article: How Healthy Is Asparagus?

The Week in Well

Here are some stories you don't want to miss:

Let's keep the conversation going. Follow Well on Instagram, or write to us at well_newsletter@nytimes.com. And check out last week's newsletter about how to stop stressing about your schedule.

FITNESS

Article Image

Theodore Tae

A 20-Minute Workout to Keep You Nimble as You Age

Training yourself to pivot and weave can help you feel more stable. These six exercises can help.

By Amanda Loudin and Theodore Tae

A pair of hands massages the shoulders of a man lying face down.

Nicholas Sansone for The New York Times

Massage Can Help After a Workout, But Not for the Reason You Think

There's no question it feels good and relaxes you. But does massage really affect sore muscles?

By Christie Aschwanden

NUTRITION NEWS

Kevin Hall, a nutrition and metabolism researcher at the National Institutes of Health, sits in a chair for a portrait. He is leaning forward on his knees and wearing a button down shirt.

Lexey Swall for The New York Times

Leading Nutrition Scientist Departs N.I.H., Citing Censorship

Kevin Hall said his work on ultraprocessed foods has been "hobbled" under the Trump administration. Scientists have been raising such concerns for months.

By Alice Callahan

A profile portrait of Marion Nestle wearing a blue top and a print scarf. She has gray curly hair.

Graham Dickie/The New York Times

At 88, a Nutritionist Meets Her Moment

After five decades in the field of nutrition, Dr. Marion Nestle thought she had seen it all. Then came "Make America Healthy Again."

By Elizabeth G. Dunn

MENTAL HEALTH

A photo collage illustration featuring images of a large red nail and various figures with their backs turned.

Vanessa Saba

Psych 101

When a Small Rejection Feels Like 'the End of the World'

For people who identify with "rejection sensitive dysphoria," perceived criticism can be overwhelming.

By Christina Caron

An illustration of a man sitting at a chair. To the right of him is another chair and a woman walking away from him.

Marta Monteiro

Ask the Therapist

I Had a Sex Dream About My Therapist. Was She Right to Be Upset?

She said I could tell her anything.

By Lori Gottlieb

Thank you for being a subscriber

Read past editions of the newsletter here.

If you're enjoying what you're reading, please consider recommending it to others. They can sign up here. Browse all of our subscriber-only newsletters here. And follow The New York Times on Instagram, Threads, Facebook and TikTok at @nytimes.

Have feedback? We'd love to hear from you. Email us at well_newsletter@nytimes.com.

The Well newsletter logo

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for Well from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Well, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Explore more subscriber-only newsletters.

Connect with us on:

facebookxwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

Share: