Tuesday, April 15, 2025

The Book Review: Fact-checking, but make it fiction

Plus: remembering Mario Vargas Llosa.
Books

April 15, 2025

This is a photograph of an anxious young man sitting at a desk while running his hands through his hair. A sheaf of papers and a coffee sit on the desk in front of him.
The title character of "The Fact Checker" works at a magazine much like The New Yorker. Hiroyuki Ito for The New York Times

Dear readers,

There is a stereotype, not entirely unfounded, that we journalists leap at any depiction of ourselves or our profession in books or onscreen. Naturally, I was intrigued to learn there's a new novel about a fact checker: one of those behind-the-scenes types who perform an essential role in journalism but rarely get the glamour-puss treatment.

"The Fact Checker," by Austin Kelley (himself a former checker), follows a young man in 2004 New York working at a somewhat fusty and highbrow periodical, though he's quite comfortable in his job. Our unnamed narrator is mopey when it comes to love and experiencing some sort of low-level masculine crisis — "a meat eater who's never killed anything" — when a cryptic figure he meets in the course of his work sends him scrambling.

I asked one of the Book Review's own checkers, Miguel Salazar, for his take on what people often get wrong about his work.

There's a lot of pressure in making sure every "hard" fact we include is bulletproof. But having been around the block I've realized the job can be deceptively slippery! We're always negotiating with writers and editors on the value of evidence and how it is presented. It feels like I'm essentially mediating what reality is with other journalists and arriving at a shared interpretation of it for public consumption.

Heady stuff! He went on:

I feel there is a timelessness to our endeavor that's persisted despite the rise of the internet, smartphones, social media and A.I., and appreciate that there are novels capturing the level of uncertainty. Ultimately, aren't we all just trying to make sense of this world?

I think we can all agree on that, no matter what personal crises we are wading through at the moment.

See you on Friday.

In other news

  • Mario Vargas Llosa, the Nobel-winning Peruvian novelist, died on Sunday at age 89. I enjoyed reading about his life, and especially this appreciation of his work by our critic Dwight Garner, who called the author "the world's savviest and most accomplished political novelist."
  • In case you missed it: Thomas Pynchon is slated to release a new novel this fall. "Shadow Ticket" is billed as the story of a private detective on the trail of a rogue Wisconsin cheese heiress, and will be Pynchon's first new book in over a decade.

FIND YOUR NEXT BOOK

This is the cover of

Editors' Choice

8 New Books We Recommend This Week

Suggested reading from critics and editors at The New York Times.

This is a collage with snippets of many book covers.

The New York Times

Spring preview

24 Works of Fiction to Read This Spring

Watch for a new "Hunger Games" prequel; a quirky romance from Emily Henry; novels by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie and Ocean Vuong; and more.

By Wilson Wong

This is a collage with snippets of many book covers.

The New York Times

21 Nonfiction Books to Read This Spring

A posthumous collection of Joan Didion's diaries, biographies of Yoko Ono and Mark Twain, a history of The Onion — and plenty more.

By Miguel Salazar and Laura Thompson

The illustration shows portions of 20 book covers mixed with squared in varying shades of green in a grid pattern.

The New York Times

20 Books Coming in April

A posthumous Joan Didion book, Emily Henry's latest romance novel, Tina Knowles's memoir and more.

RECENT BOOK REVIEWS

A painting of Christ extending a forbidding hand toward a kneeling woman who looks distressed.

Nonfiction

2,000 Years Later, Christians Are Still Worrying About Sex

In "Lower Than the Angels," the historian Diarmaid MacCulloch traces two millenniums of libidinal frustration.

By Spencer Strub

A photo illustration of two hands holding a digital camera, with a close-up of an eye on the screen.

Nonfiction

A Memoir of What A.I. Giveth, and What It Taketh Away

"Searches," by Vauhini Vara, is both a memoir and a critical study of our digital selves.

By Dwight Garner

A photograph of firefighters standing on the smoldering remains of a forest with a darkened sky full of red smoke behind them.

Nonfiction

This Global Warming Book Is a Token From Another World

"What's Left," by Malcolm Harris, arrives at a particularly difficult time to consider anything beyond our immediate turmoil.

By Adam Tooze

A painting of the Virgin Mary being crowned, with cherubs and angels surrounding her.

Fiction

Murder, Medicis and Old Masters in a Historical Whodunit

Laurent Binet's novel "Perspective(s)" begins with an artist lying dead in a Florentine chapel.

By Chelsea Leu

Elon Musk, in a baseball cap, sunglasses, and a dark blazer, hoists a bright red chain saw in the air while Javier Milei, the president of Argentina, stands next to him in a blue jacket, shirt and tie, beaming, with both fists raised.

Nonfiction

The Far Right's Love-Hate Relationship With Globalization

A new book by the historian Quinn Slobodian examines right-wing figures who have positioned themselves as populist critics of neoliberalism while weaponizing some of its founders' ideas.

By Jennifer Szalai

An illustration of a rearview mirror with a reflection of a house in it.

Fiction

A Novel That Takes On Life's Greatest Mystery: Our Parents

In "The Imagined Life," a writer searches his home state and his buried memories for answers about his long-lost father.

By Rand Richards Cooper

The illustration shows abstract figures of a man and woman in shades of pink and red, both covering their faces with one hand. They are surrounded by more vague human silhouettes in shades of blue, gray and tan.

Fiction

An Absurd Dystopia Asks, What Happens to Families When Sex Is Taboo?

Sayaka Murata's novel "Vanishing World" envisions an alternate universe where artificial insemination is the global norm, and sex takes a back seat.

By Madeleine Feeny

Love this email? Forward to a friend.

Want this email? Sign-up here.

Have a suggestion for this email? Then send us a note at books@nytimes.com.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for Books from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Books, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

xwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

Share: